Over 1,000 Tips Lead Cops Nowhere in Teacher Kidnapping Case

March 28, 2017 | Updated: 3:35 a.m., March 28, 2017

The search for teenager Elizabeth Thomas and the high school teacher police believe kidnapped her two weeks ago has generated more than 1,000 leads, most of them fruitless, the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation said Monday.

Though some of the tips remain under investigation, authorities have not been able to confirm anyone actually saw the girl or her alleged abductor, spokesman Josh DeVine said.

"We have 904 closed leads, 154 open, and no confirmed sightings," he said in an email.

Fugitive Ex-teacher Accused of Kidnapping Teen Reportedly Seen in Texas: Police

Police say Tad Cummins, 50, a teacher at Culleoka Unit School, absconded with 15-year-old Elizabeth on March 13, more than a month after he was suspended from his teaching duties following an investigation into a student's claim she saw Cummins and Elizabeth kissing in his classroom.

The allegation couldn't be confirmed by the school -- police have since charged Cummins with sexual misconduct with a minor -- but the school removed Elizabeth from his class and instructed the teacher not to allow her in his classroom.

Cummins defied the order, according to school records, and was suspended. He was fired after police issued an Amber Alert for Elizabeth and charged Cummins with aggravated kidnapping in her disappearance, according to police and the school district.

Advertisement

Elizabeth's brother, James, has said that before his sister disappeared she told another sibling to call police if she didn't come home by 6 p.m. on March 13. There was no school that day, and police say a friend dropped her off at a Columbia restaurant.

Investigators say they believe Elizabeth and Cummins were in Decatur, Alabama, later that day. Then, they vanished.

Investigators now say they believe that before the pair disappeared, they sent each other romantic missives using the drafts folder of Cummins' school email account, TV station WAAY reported.

Advertisement

In one email, Cummins wrote, "'I saw you standing next to your backpack this morning' and makes a reference to a body part of hers and how nice that looked," Detective Marcus Albright of the Maury County Sheriff's Department told the station.

To communicate, Elizabeth or Cummins would write the other an email, often inappropriate, and save it as a draft, District Attorney Brent Cooper told WAAY. The other then would log in, read the message, delete it and write a reply, again saving it as a draft, he said.

"If you read them, you would immediately recognize you are reading messages between two people who have a romantic interest in each other," Cooper told WAAY.

Cooper would not go into further detail, according to the station. He said Elizabeth and Cummins sent each other romantic messages via his email account, but would not elaborate. The TBI referred all questions about the emails to Cooper.

The prosecutor also posted a direct appeal to Cummins via the YouTube page of a news director at a local radio station.

Advertisement

"I want to ask you just to do the right thing, and I'm not asking you to turn yourself in," Cooper said. "I'm not asking you to call the police. I'm not worried about that at this point. What we're worried about is Elizabeth and her safety. It's just time to let her come home. Just release her. Drop her off somewhere, somewhere safe, somewhere where she can be found and let her get back home to her family, and we'll worry about what's going to happen to you later."

Meanwhile, a Tennessee District Attorney says Cummins could walk away with only a misdemeanor.

Investigators have repeatedly said it doesn't matter if the teen willingly left with her teacher.

However, Tennessee law doesn't necessarily reflect that statement. In fact, whether or not she went willingly will play a huge role in determining whether or not the District Attorney can prove kidnapping, Maury County District Attorney Brent Cooper told WHNT.

Advertisement

"If she comes back and she is absolutely adamant that this is all voluntary, her own doing, that he didn't touch her, it's going to be difficult to prove that," said Cooper.

Cooper said one of the challenges is Elizabeth's age. She's already fifteen, and it takes a while to move a criminal case to trial.

"She may not be an adult by that time, but she's going to look like it. And we're going to have to convince twelve people that it was coercion the way that he went about convincing her to leave," said Cooper.

While she isn't an adult, the state of Tennessee's current kidnapping law treats her that way.

"Our kidnapping statute says in essence through it's silence on that issue. It's saying that you can be between 13 and 18 and you can legally make the mature decision to leave your family and run off with a person never to be seen again," said Cooper.

Advertisement

That's why he is hoping to help change the law.

"The statue should say if an adult, especially one in an authority position over a child, removes a child with or without that child's consent,  if it's without the consent of the parents or guardians, that should be a crime," said Cooper.

The District Attorney said he is unsure what a final bill proposal would look like. However, he believes this case will be a reason for lawmakers to list. He said getting something into law will cost the state time and money. ​