Bill Cosby Jury Says They Can’t Reach Verdict, Judge Orders Them to Try Again

Jurors in Bill Cosby's assault trial began their third day of deliberations on Wednesday in a case closely watched by the public as well as the dozens of women who have accused Cosby of similar misconduct.

After four days of deliberating, jurors in Bill Cosby’s trial said they are deadlocked and cannot come to a unanimous decision on any of the three charges against the comedian.

So now what?

Judge orders them to try again

First, Judge Steven O’Neill sent them back into deliberations in another attempt to reach a verdict, which must be unanimous. Cosby, 79, has pleaded not guilty to three charges of aggravated indecent assault.

In court Thursday, O’Neill read to jurors what is commonly known as the Allen Charge, or the “dynamite charge,” which is a set of instructions that asks jurors to re-examine their own views and opinions in order to reach a decision. It’s called the Spencer Charge in Pennsylvania, according to Jim Koval, director of communications for the Pennsylvania Courts.

“I am required to read you an instruction. The jury foreman has informed me that you are deadlocked,” O’Neill said. “If you are still deadlocked you should report that to me. If you’ve reached a unanimous decision on some of the charges, please report that back to me.”

There is no rule on how many times O’Neill can order jurors back to work under the Spencer Charge.

Advertisement

The jury could come back with a verdict

After further deliberations, jurors could still return a unanimous verdict. There are three possibilities:

Guilty on all counts. Not guilty on all counts. Mixed verdict, finding guilty on some but not guilty on others.

Advertisement

The 12-person jury is made up of four white women, six white men, one black woman and one black man. They were bused in from Allegheny County near Pittsburgh and have been sequestered in a hotel for the trial.

Mistrial could be declared

If the jury tries again and is still deadlocked, it would be considered a “hung jury” and opens up the possibility that O’Neill will declare a mistrial.

In that case, Cosby would not be found guilty, nor would he be acquitted. Following the declaration of a mistrial, prosecutors may choose to retry the case with a different set of jurors, or they may cut their losses.

Prosecutors say Cosby drugged and sexually assaulted Andrea Constand, a former Temple University employee, at his Pennsylvania home in January 2004. The case has little forensic evidence, and legal experts have said it fits the “he said-she said” dynamic so common to sexual offense cases.

The trial began on June 5, and the jury began deliberating Monday evening. After 31 hours of deliberations, jurors said they were deadlocked.

CNN’s Lawrence Crook III, Jean Casarez and Laura Dolan contributed to this report.